This post contains affiliate links, and we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. These opinions come from real, hands-on experience with these hosting providers, helping local businesses build sites that get results.
When you run a small business here on Long Island, your website isn’t just a digital brochure — it’s your storefront, your marketing hub, and often your first impression with new customers.
And whether you’re a landscaper in Sayville, a café owner in Port Washington, or an accountant in Garden City, there’s one thing your website can’t afford to have: slow, unreliable web hosting.
After building and managing hundreds of websites for local businesses over the past 15 years, I’ve tested just about every major hosting company out there. Some make your life easier. Others… not so much.
In this review, I’m breaking down four popular hosting providers I’ve personally used — Bluehost, HostPapa, Pressable, and Network Solutions — and sharing which one we recommend most often to our Long Island clients looking for affordable, reliable, small business web hosting.
(Note: Originally, GoDaddy was on this list, but their customer support has gone down the tubes in recent years, and they nickel and dime you on every little thing when an upgrade is needed or an issue arises. We still use them to manage some of our businesses’ websites but that’s just because migrating proves to be not worth the hassle. )
Why Your Web Hosting Choice Matters
Most Long Island business owners spend hours picking colors, photos, and copy for their website — but forget that hosting is the foundation that keeps it all running smoothly.
If your hosting is slow or unreliable:
- Customers won’t wait for your page to load — they’ll hit the back button.
- Local SEO will be impacted: Google will rank your site lower in search results.
- You’ll waste hours with support when your site goes down.
But when you pick the right host, your website loads fast, stays online, website maintenance is a breeze, and becomes a real business asset — not a headache.
So let’s look at which providers actually deliver that kind of reliability and value.
Bluehost: Our #1 Recommended Hosting for Long Island Small Businesses
If you’ve ever Googled “best web hosting for small business,” Bluehost almost always comes up — and for good reason.
For years, it’s been one of the most beginner-friendly, budget-friendly hosting providers, and it’s the one we use and recommend most often for local small business websites.
Why We Recommend Bluehost
- Affordable plans starting around $2.95/month
- 1-click WordPress installation — no tech skills needed
- Free domain and SSL certificate for the first year
- Easy-to-use dashboard that even non-tech users can manage
- Solid uptime (99.9%) and fast loading times
- 24/7 chat and phone support from a U.S.-based team
Bluehost is officially recommended by WordPress.org, and from my experience, it’s the smoothest option for small businesses that just need their website to work.
We’ve hosted dozens of client sites on Bluehost — from landscapers and construction companies to accountants and yoga studios — and it continues to be the most reliable, hassle-free choice for small business owners.
★ Our #1 pick for Long Island small business websites.
And by the way, if you’re building your new site on WordPress, check out our Astra Theme Review — it’s the theme we use with most of our Bluehost builds for its speed, flexibility, and local SEO performance.
HostPapa: Great Customer Support and Eco-Friendly Hosting
HostPapa is a Canadian-based hosting company that’s quietly built a great reputation among small business owners — especially for their personal support and green hosting initiatives.
Why We Like HostPapa
- Pricing starts around $3.95/month
- Excellent live chat support — real humans who care
- Free domain and SSL
- 100% powered by renewable energy
- Good performance for small WordPress sites
HostPapa’s support team stands out — especially for beginners. If you’re new to hosting and like having someone walk you through setup or email configuration, they’re great at that.
It’s a solid alternative to Bluehost for business owners who value a personal touch or sustainability.
Prefer not to deal with the tech setup?
We’ve got you covered. We’ll handle the hosting, WordPress install, theme setup, and optimization — so you can focus on running your Long Island business.
Pressable: Premium Managed WordPress Hosting
Pressable is like the Tesla of web hosting — built for performance, security, and ease of management.
It’s owned by Automattic, the same company behind WordPress.com, and offers a fully managed WordPress hosting experience.
What Makes Pressable Stand Out
- Incredibly fast, secure WordPress hosting
- Automatic updates, daily backups, and malware scanning
- One-click staging environments for testing changes
- Uptime guarantees and priority support
The tradeoff? It’s pricier — starting around $25/month.
But for growing Long Island businesses that get consistent website traffic or want peace of mind knowing a professional team is managing their hosting, Pressable is worth every penny.
Network Solutions: A Trusted Name, But Showing Its Age
Network Solutions has been around forever.
If you registered a domain back in the early 2000s, chances are it was with them.
And while their domain services are still decent, their hosting platform hasn’t quite kept up with modern expectations.
What You Should Know
- Plans start around $6.99/month
- Decent uptime, but slower speeds than others
- Interface and dashboard feel dated
- Support can be hit or miss depending on plan
If you already have your domain with Network Solutions and prefer keeping everything in one place, it can be convenient.
But if you’re starting fresh or want better performance and pricing, Bluehost or HostPapa will serve you better.
Comparison: The Best Web Hosting for Long Island Small Businesses
| Host | Starting Price | Ease of Use | Performance | Support | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bluehost | ~$2.95/mo | Best all-around for Long Island small business | |||
| HostPapa | ~$3.95/mo | Great customer support & eco-friendly | |||
| Pressable | ~$25/mo | Managed hosting for growing businesses | |||
| Network Solutions | ~$6.99/mo | Legacy users, simple setups |
What We Look For in a Good Web Host
When we recommend hosting to Long Island businesses, we look for more than price.
Here’s what actually matters:
- Uptime reliability: At least 99.9%
- Speed: Local servers and optimized caching
- Ease of use: A dashboard you don’t need a tech degree to use
- Scalability: Ability to grow as your traffic increases
- Support: Fast response times when things go wrong
- Value: Clear pricing and features that match what you pay for
Bluehost checks every one of these boxes — which is why it’s still our go-to recommendation year after year.
Final Thoughts: Bluehost Is the Smart Choice for Long Island Small Business Websites
Here’s the truth: most small business owners don’t need enterprise-level hosting or complex managed servers.
You need a platform that’s fast, secure, affordable, and easy to use.
Bluehost hits that sweet spot — and it’s why we continue to host and recommend it for the majority of our Long Island web design clients.
If you’re launching a new website or upgrading an old one, Bluehost gives you everything you need to get online quickly and grow your digital presence with confidence.
Get Bluehost Hosting
Fast, reliable, and trusted by millions of small businesses — including many right here on Long Island.
Prefer not to deal with the tech setup?
We’ve got you covered. We’ll handle the hosting, WordPress install, theme setup, and optimization — so you can focus on running your Long Island business.
